top of page

Indulge Your Sweet Tooth: Discover the Top Ten Local Ice Cream Shops on Anna Maria Island

Anna Maria Island top ten ice cream

Sun-kissed beaches, turquoise waters, and the gentle sea breeze – Anna Maria Island is a paradise on Florida's Gulf Coast. And what better way to beat the heat and savor the island vibes than with a scoop of delicious ice cream? Whether you're a regular looking for a new favorite spot or a first-timer seeking a memorable treat, we've compiled a list of the top ten local ice cream shops that are sure to satisfy your cravings.

1. Dips Ice Cream – A true local favorite, Dips Ice Cream has earned its place as the #1 ice cream shop on Anna Maria Island for a reason. Nestled within the General Store on Pine Avenue, this family-owned and operated shop boasts a delightful range of flavors that have earned them their reputation. Don't miss their enchanting Christmas light display during the holidays! Visit them at 9801 Gulf Drive, Anna Maria, FL 34216.

2. Small Town Creamery – For those seeking a dose of nostalgia and a sprinkle of fun, Small Town Creamery is the place to be. With homemade fudge, waffle cones, cold brew, and more, this creamery is a treasure trove of treats. Plus, its playful toy selection and captivating displays make it a hit with kids and adults alike. Discover this gem at 5404 Marina Dr, Holmes Beach, FL 34217.

3. Two Scoops Ice Cream Parlor & Coffee Café – Located in Bayview Plaza, Two Scoops is much more than an ice cream parlor. Boasting 32 flavors of homemade ice cream, this spot has quickly become an island favorite. Indulge in a delicious breakfast or lunch, and explore their delectable offerings at 101 S. Bay Blvd, Anna Maria, FL.

4. Anna Maria Island Creamery and Bakery – This family-owned gem offers an array of delights, from original handmade Italian Gelato and sorbets to pastries, truffles, and locally roasted gourmet coffee. Located at 9801 Gulf Dr, Anna Maria, FL 34216, this creamery and bakery is a must-visit for all dessert enthusiasts.

Scooping Gelato on Anna Maria Island

5. Holy Cow Ice Cream & Other Cool Stuff – For over a decade, Holy Cow has been serving up frozen delights in the heart of Anna Maria Island. With a prime location near Walgreens, this family-owned establishment offers an extensive array of treats, including milkshakes, malts, 36 flavors of homemade ice cream, soft serve, almond milk options, and even sugar-free delights.There is truly something for everyone to savor. Pay them a visit at 3234 E Bay Dr, Holmes Beach, FL 34217.

6. Island Scoops – Located in the south end of the island, you will find Island Scoops just steps away from the white sands of Bradenton Beach. Indulge in the likes of ice cream flights, sumptuous sundaes, inventive ice cream nachos, freshly baked treats, an assortment of candies, and more. Visit them at 103B Gulf Drive North, Bradenton Beach, FL 34217.

7. Gelato-go Anna Maria Island – If you're craving an authentic taste of Italy, Gelato-go on Historic Bridge Street is your destination. This newer addition to the ice cream scene offers not just Gelato but also paninis, pastries, and coffee, all in the heart of the island at 119 Bridge St, Bradenton Beach, FL 34217.

8. Frosty Oasis – A newcomer that's already making waves, Frosty Oasis brings creativity to the ice cream game. With rotating Dole whip flavors and unique frozen treats like turtle cones and key lime ice cream pie, this shop is a haven for the adventurous palate. Explore their offerings at 5602 Marina Dr Unit C, Holmes Beach, FL 34217.

9. Baskin Robbins – A classic in the ice cream world, Baskin Robbins has a locally owned and operated franchise on the island. With its iconic 31 flavors and ice cream cakes, you can't go wrong with a visit to this shop. And the best part? It's conveniently located inside Dunkin Donuts at 3302 E Bay Dr, Holmes Beach, FL.

10. Tyler’s Ice Cream – While not technically on the island, Tyler's Ice Cream is a nearby gem in Cortez dating back to 1984. This staple has expanded to two additional locations, offering gourmet old fashioned ice cream made fresh on-site. Discover Tyler's at 11904 Cortez Rd W, Cortez, FL 34215.

Anna Maria Island's ice cream shops offer a spectrum of sweet delights that are sure to captivate your taste buds. Whether you're a local exploring your options or a visitor seeking the perfect scoop, these top ten ice cream shops are a treat-filled adventure waiting to happen. Explore the flavors, enjoy the ambiance, and make memories on this charming Gulf Coast island.


Stay with Us

Beach Boutique Rentals
Check Availability Now

bottom of page