top of page

Wish Upon a Starfish

2 Blocks to the beach







Pet friendly

Wish Upon a Starfish

Wish Upon a Starfish, where all your island dreams come true! This elevated Key West style 3 bedroom home is truly paradise found.

*Features include*

  • 3 bedrooms with 3 full attached baths

  • Private heated pool

  • Beach chairs and wagon and toys

  • Washer and dryer

  • Ping pong table

  • Bicycles

  • Outdoor shower

  • Family friendly, stocked with children's supplies

  • Large family dining table in the poolside lanai

  • Rooftop deck

  • 2 blocks to the beach!

This home is located in a quiet and peaceful Anna Maria Island neighborhood. Too many wonderful features to list including vaulted ceilings, open floor plan and huge ground floor lanai with French doors opening up to the private heated pool. You will enjoy your coffee on the spacious front deck. Relax with one of the many books provided in the library or a cocktail in the evening.

The fully equipped kitchen has everything you need to prepare a quick snack for your family at the breakfast bar or a full dinner in the dining room. The living room invites you to relax, kick-back and enjoy your favorite TV shows on the flat screen smart TV.

Wish Upon a Starfish was created with families in mind. The home provides a pack n' play, high chair, baby gates, and a bouncy chair so you can forget about having to travel with these extra items. The kids will love the bedroom with 2 twin over full bunk sets. This room also offers its own private bathroom with walk in shower and water closet.

The Queen size guest bedroom features a sleep number adjustable bed and an ensuite Jack and Jill bathroom which is also accessible through the hallway. The entire 3rd floor is where you will find the beautiful master bedroom with brand new king size bed, walk-in closet and full bath with beautiful tiled shower. Head up to the roof for gorgeous sunset views and peeks of the water in the evening.

From the house you will find an easy stroll down 2 and a half blocks to the gorgeous sugar white sand beaches of Anna Maria. Wish Upon a Starfish is conveniently located midway between Holmes Beach and the beautiful North End of the island where you will have the best of both worlds at your fingertips.

We generally require a minimum stay of 7 nights with Saturday check-in during the high season. We are more flexible in the off season so please send us a message if your dates appear unavailable. We may be able to accommodate you!

This rental is dog friendly! A fee of $150 + tax is required in advance for each dog you are bringing.


2 pets maximum unless granted an exception. Weight limit of 75 lbs maximum total for 1 pet or 120 lbs total for 2 pets.

Due to property insurance policies and liability concerns NO dangerous breeds or aggressive animals are allowed. The following breeds (purebred or crossbred) are not permitted:

  • Pit Bull

  • Akita

  • Rottweiler

  • German Shepherd

  • Siberian Husky

  • Malamute

  • Doberman Pinscher

  • Chows

  • Any Wolf-dog hybrid

  • Any other dog that has been known to have bitten anyone


Anna Maria Island is a family community and the city imposes a strict noise ordinance. Please adhere to our good neighbor policy and observe the local quiet hours between 10 pm and 8 am. No loud music is allowed during these hours along with any other noise which may disturb the neighbors.

We do not accept reservations from any guests under the age of 25. The primary guest will be required to provide proof of age and must occupy the rental home for the duration of the reservation.

This home provides off-street parking for up to 3 vehicles.

A minimum deposit of 25% of the total rental fee is due at the time of booking. If the arrival date is within 60 days, payment is due in full. For information regarding our cancellation policy, please click here.


Wish Upon a Starfish


AMENITIES (scroll through)
Basic soap
Starter toilet paper
Starter paper towels
Linens provided
Towels provided
Hair dryer
Washing machine
Clothes dryer
Iron & Board
Wireless internet
Baby gate
Pack n play
Standard coffee maker
Ping pong table
Heated pool
Private pool
Outdoor shower
Beach chairs
Beach umbrella
Beach wagon/cart
Beach towels
Sun loungers
BBQ grill
Rooftop deck
Free parking on premises


Wish Upon a Starfish